Compare and contrast greek democracy and roman republic

Do models need college degrees? The following is by and according to the U.

Compare and contrast greek democracy and roman republic

Today, although "democracy" and "republic" are often used interchangeably, in ancient times they referred to distinct political systems. A democracy and a republic each had its own distinct institutional arrangements based on different ideas about what it meant for citizens to participate in the political process.

Although the United States reflects the influence of both democracies and republics, these influences can at times be in tension with one another: While a democracy represents the principle of majority rule, a republic uses institutions to check and balance the power of majorities.

Origin Democracy was invented by the ancient Athenians in the sixth century B. It comes from the ancient Greek word "demos" or people and "kratos," meaning rule. Democracy was a political community in which the people, or the collective body of active citizens, exercised political power.

In contrast, the term "republic" is Roman in origin and has traditionally been dated back to B. It comes from the Latin word "res," meaning thing or matter, and "publica," meaning public or common. The republic, therefore, meant the public matter, the thing that is in common among the people.

Ancient Democratic Institutions One of the most important differences between ancient Greek democracy and ancient Roman Republicanism was institutional. Both ancient Greeks and Roman thinkers conceived of society as containing two permanently distinct and mutually antagonistic groups: Greek democracy and Roman republicanism dealt with this fact in different ways.

For Greek thinkers, democracy was simply the rule of the many over the few, whereas aristocracy or oligarchy was the rule of the few over the many. Power could only be held by the masses or by the elite.

Ancient Republican Institutions In contrast to Greek democracy, the Roman republic had a more complex institutional arrangement. Instead of a set of institutions through which one single group exercised power, the Roman republic contained multiple institutions that allowed both the few and the many to take part in political rule.

In Rome, the few, or the patrician class, were represented by the senate, an exclusively aristocratic institution. The masses, or the plebeians, had their own institutional source of power in the councils and the popular assemblies.

In this way, Roman political thinkers hoped to achieve stability by giving both the masses and the elites some institutional stake in political power.

Compare and contrast greek democracy and roman republic

How They Participated According to some scholars, such as Nadia Urbinati, ancient democracies and republics also allowed for different forms of popular participation. In ancient democratic Athens, the medium of speech, or "logos," was the primary way that citizens participated in political life.

Expert Answers

In the Roman republic, by contrast, the medium for popular participation was acclamation rather than deliberation. The mass of the people, physically present in the assembly, would signify its power by either cheering or protesting in response to a speech.

The people acclaimed or rejected but did little deliberation.The ancient Roman and Greek civilizations had well-organized political processes that greatly influenced the manner in which later governments were structured in Europe and the United States.

Get an answer for 'How did Rome's republic differ from Greek democracy? How were they similar?' and find homework help for other History questions at eNotes.

the period of the Roman Republic. Oct 19,  · Best Answer: The Athenian Democracy remains a unique and intriguing experiment in direct democracy where the people do not elect representatives to vote on their behalf but vote on legislation and executive bills in their own right.

The Roman Republic was more of a time frame nevertheless was governed by a Status: Resolved. Greek Democracy and the Roman Republic contributed greatly to the development of the modern world, bringing into it the notions of democracy and republic.

The evolution of these concepts took them to a level much higher than one present in Ancient Greece and Rome respectively. What is the difference between the US government, Roman Republic, and Athenian democracy? How did Athenian democracy differ from Roman republicanism?

Ask New Question. The only comparable thing in Athenian democracy and the Roman Republic is that bills were voted on by popular assemblies.

Difference between roman republic and athenian democracy